A
AlexB
Guest
I hope Augustus will see it. I want to know his opinion.
A test conducted today.
Home computer
System: Dell GX280
Processor Type; Intel Pentium 4 CPU: 3.8 GHz
Clock speed: 3.80 GHz
Bus Speed: 800 GHz
Processor L2 Cash 1 Mb
Processor ID: 0F41
Hyperthreading: Yes
64-Bit - No
Memory Slots: Memory Speed: 533 MHz. Technology: DDR2 SDRAM
DIMM 1 1 GB
DIMM 2 empty
DIMM 3 1 GB
DIMM 4 empty
Drives: SATA - 2
Vista Ultimate on C:, XP Pro on D:
Vista XP
Boot time: 44"" 1'24"
*******************************************************
Office machine GX-280, pretty much the same configuration.
Vista XP
Boot time: 56" 1'11"
Shutdown 1'05" -----
Another machine at the office:
OEM DELL T7400
223-4704 1 Dell Precision T7400 Mini-Tower, Quad Core Xeon Proc X5450,
3.00GHz, 2X 6MB L2 Cache,1333MHz
311-7681 1 4GB, DDR2 ECC SDRAM Memory 667MHz, 4X1GB, Dell Precision T5400
320-5868 1 nVidia Quadro FX1700 512MB dual DVI Graphics Card, Dell Precision
T3400
341-5353 1 250GB SATA 3.0Gb/s, 7200RPM HardDrive with 8MB DataBurst Cache,
Dell Precision T7400/5400
341-5374 1 C6 All SATA Hard Drives RAID 0 for 2 Hard Drives Dell Precision
T7400
420-6645 1 Microsoft Windows Vista Ultimate Edition, English with Media,
Dell Precision Workstation
430-1680 1 Broadcom NetXtreme 10/100/1000Gigabit Ethernet controller PCI
Express,Dell Precision 490/690
313-5937 1 16XDVD AND 16XDVD+/-RW w/Cyberlink Power DVD,Roxio Digital
Creator Dell Edition Dell Precision T7400
313-5883 1 Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeMusic(D), w/Dolby Digital 5.1 Vista,
Dell Precision T7400/5400
341-5359 1 250GB SATA 3.0Gb/s, 7200RPM Additional NCQ HardDrive with 8MB
DataBurst Cache, DellPrecision T7400/5400
For some reason the box came in with an extra 16XDVD+/-R which I did not
order and it is not in the documentation.
Vista OEM boot: 1'46" Shutdown 34.9"
Methodology:
Trolls around here quote various questionable "scientific" evidence in
support of their very biased opinions. Of course, they have no idea what an
accurate measurement is. It involves a lot of factors to control and
defining parameters carefully.
It is hard to make sure that the software on both XP and Vista are
equivalent but this seems to be roughly the case in my systems. I migrated
from XP to Vista taking all software with me and the projects continues for
years. Obviously on Vista now I have more source code for the same projects
than on XP.
All thing considered I am confident Vista is faster in boot than XP. I am
confident the man who posted that caricature result yesterday made a bogus.
I do have to mention the methodology.
In Vista the boot time was measured with a stop watch from the moment I
pressed the power button to the moment the sign in window with the globe
appeared and the music played. The step when I entered the password was
excluded. After that Vista dwindles a bit with the ring (counterpart of the
hour glass) rolling. It probably takes about 10 sec. That can be added to
the measurement. I doubt it is more than that.
In XP the situation is slightly different. At work XP shows a PW window
which is closed by a mouse click then the system proceed to load services.
This takes about 2 secs. The stopwatch is running. The hourglass is there to
see. You cannot do anything until it disappears. Once it disappeared THE
FIRST TIME I press the stopwatch. I know it is not the end of the story. In
about 5 secs it shows up again, then disappears, then appears again.
I think the whole thing takes roughly 20". Thus this time may be added to
XP. It is somewhat similar at the home system which has markedly less
software.
I was surprised that a much faster Vista (in terms of the app run) boots
slower than the ones on slower computers.
I hope Augustus will comment.
A test conducted today.
Home computer
System: Dell GX280
Processor Type; Intel Pentium 4 CPU: 3.8 GHz
Clock speed: 3.80 GHz
Bus Speed: 800 GHz
Processor L2 Cash 1 Mb
Processor ID: 0F41
Hyperthreading: Yes
64-Bit - No
Memory Slots: Memory Speed: 533 MHz. Technology: DDR2 SDRAM
DIMM 1 1 GB
DIMM 2 empty
DIMM 3 1 GB
DIMM 4 empty
Drives: SATA - 2
Vista Ultimate on C:, XP Pro on D:
Vista XP
Boot time: 44"" 1'24"
*******************************************************
Office machine GX-280, pretty much the same configuration.
Vista XP
Boot time: 56" 1'11"
Shutdown 1'05" -----
Another machine at the office:
OEM DELL T7400
223-4704 1 Dell Precision T7400 Mini-Tower, Quad Core Xeon Proc X5450,
3.00GHz, 2X 6MB L2 Cache,1333MHz
311-7681 1 4GB, DDR2 ECC SDRAM Memory 667MHz, 4X1GB, Dell Precision T5400
320-5868 1 nVidia Quadro FX1700 512MB dual DVI Graphics Card, Dell Precision
T3400
341-5353 1 250GB SATA 3.0Gb/s, 7200RPM HardDrive with 8MB DataBurst Cache,
Dell Precision T7400/5400
341-5374 1 C6 All SATA Hard Drives RAID 0 for 2 Hard Drives Dell Precision
T7400
420-6645 1 Microsoft Windows Vista Ultimate Edition, English with Media,
Dell Precision Workstation
430-1680 1 Broadcom NetXtreme 10/100/1000Gigabit Ethernet controller PCI
Express,Dell Precision 490/690
313-5937 1 16XDVD AND 16XDVD+/-RW w/Cyberlink Power DVD,Roxio Digital
Creator Dell Edition Dell Precision T7400
313-5883 1 Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeMusic(D), w/Dolby Digital 5.1 Vista,
Dell Precision T7400/5400
341-5359 1 250GB SATA 3.0Gb/s, 7200RPM Additional NCQ HardDrive with 8MB
DataBurst Cache, DellPrecision T7400/5400
For some reason the box came in with an extra 16XDVD+/-R which I did not
order and it is not in the documentation.
Vista OEM boot: 1'46" Shutdown 34.9"
Methodology:
Trolls around here quote various questionable "scientific" evidence in
support of their very biased opinions. Of course, they have no idea what an
accurate measurement is. It involves a lot of factors to control and
defining parameters carefully.
It is hard to make sure that the software on both XP and Vista are
equivalent but this seems to be roughly the case in my systems. I migrated
from XP to Vista taking all software with me and the projects continues for
years. Obviously on Vista now I have more source code for the same projects
than on XP.
All thing considered I am confident Vista is faster in boot than XP. I am
confident the man who posted that caricature result yesterday made a bogus.
I do have to mention the methodology.
In Vista the boot time was measured with a stop watch from the moment I
pressed the power button to the moment the sign in window with the globe
appeared and the music played. The step when I entered the password was
excluded. After that Vista dwindles a bit with the ring (counterpart of the
hour glass) rolling. It probably takes about 10 sec. That can be added to
the measurement. I doubt it is more than that.
In XP the situation is slightly different. At work XP shows a PW window
which is closed by a mouse click then the system proceed to load services.
This takes about 2 secs. The stopwatch is running. The hourglass is there to
see. You cannot do anything until it disappears. Once it disappeared THE
FIRST TIME I press the stopwatch. I know it is not the end of the story. In
about 5 secs it shows up again, then disappears, then appears again.
I think the whole thing takes roughly 20". Thus this time may be added to
XP. It is somewhat similar at the home system which has markedly less
software.
I was surprised that a much faster Vista (in terms of the app run) boots
slower than the ones on slower computers.
I hope Augustus will comment.